JOURNALIST: Mr. Hübner, looking at your career, one question is specially interesting to me: what do you think of music-teaching and particularly of composition-teaching at an academy of music?

PETER HÜBNER: Just listen to what Beethoven says about this:

In my opinion, composition-teaching – as it is officially intended at an academy of music – is pure nonsense. In such a way, only the mediocre is supported. And what becomes of the mediocre? In an “ideal case” a professor of composition, a music professor or the head of a music department at a radio and/or TV station or editorial department of a newspaper, or a conductor etc.

I am not saying that all professors of composition are a dead loss.
Bernd Alois Zimmermann, Herbert Eimert and several others demonstrate very clearly that they can be outstanding experts.

JOURNALIST: You studied composition under Zimmermann at the music university Cologne. What was this teaching like?

PETER HÜBNER: Once a week I met Professor Zimmermann in a nice cafe in the Aachener Street – not far from his flat. We sat opposite each other in the corner of a Spanish-style tavern – he with a miniature bottle of champagne, called Pikkolo, and I with a cup of tea, and we spoke about philosophical borderline questions reaching into the area of music.

The approach to our talks, however, was never music, but always philosophy. For both of us, music was always only a means to the end of bringing philosophical ideas closer to other people, which cannot be brought closer through words alone.

Not a single note was mentioned or even recorded or discussed, it was about the meaning and use of music in the field of cognition of the world in general.

Bernd Alois Zimmermann was a man of immense philosophical scope, and his great musical scope was only the expression of this mental scope – that is its effectiveness, but not its cause. The experts around him only saw, as far as I can tell, his music, but not what moved him inside, and was a basis for his music as a philosophical concept.

Thus, he didn’t give me any music-teaching in the usual sense, but he possibly gave me the most dignified music-teaching which exists. He expressed to me the mental and philosophical basis of his musical work – and this he did very profoundly and extensively.

He was open-minded – especially in the field of transcendental philosophical questions. He was a very serious composer – in contrast to superficial, I never saw him laugh superficially – , but he had the natural inner cheerfulness of a serious person.

JOURNALIST: So, your lessons at the academy of music in Cologne took place in a cafe in the Aachener Street, am I right? ^Barbirolli